
Yesterday was supposed to have been the coming out party of the GOP's response to Barack Obama: Bobby Jindal. It wasn't always planned this way, however. The Louisiana Governor was tapped back in September to deliver the keynote address at the Republican National Convention in an effort to mirror Obama's 2004 keynote address for the Democrats. That speech catapulted Obama to superstardom and eventually to Pennsylvania Avenue, so it was the hope of many on the Republican side that Jindal would do the same. However, a hurricane named Gustav got in the way and prevented Jindal from attending the event. You see, hurricanes can be a bit of a problem in Louisiana (although Gustav aided the Republicans up north by preventing Bush from showing up personally), so the Jindal unveiling was left for another time.
In the meantime many, including myself, decided to look into this new character. To any liberal there is nothing more frightening than the thought of a Republican that can draw comparisons to Barack Obama, so Jindal was downright petrifying - as an idea, at least. Reviewing his record, however, I quickly discovered that there was nothing really to fear. Jindal is a Republican's Republican. In every way that Obama breaks the mold of the typical politician, Jindal fits it. He's got a perfect voting record against reproductive rights, a perfect voting record for the National Rifle Association (even being honored by the trigger-happy outift), and he's alarmingly obsessed with tax cuts.
Like any highly thought of Republican, Jindal believes tax cuts are the answer to everything. No problem is too small or unrelated to not be solved by simply allowing rich people to keep more of their money. How do we raise the quality of education in the country? Tax cut! How do we solve the deficit problem? Tax cut! What do we do about ballplayers taking steroids? Tax cut! People that wait until they board the bus to search for their MetroCard, who crack their knuckles in public, who don't clean up after their dogs? Tax cut, tax cut, tax cut! I could imagine Jindal standing on the levees during Hurricane Gustav and shouting at the maelstrom about how he would give it a tax cut if it just went away.
Jindal's also quite adept at convincing poor people that they will somehow benefit from these tax cuts (as if anyone like Tom DeLay would ever fight tooth and nail for a tax cut for a poor southern family of five instead of the monied interests that put him where he is). This last point makes Jindal a great Republican. And that's why they were so excited about him. Not only is he just like the other GOPers (which Republicans need to see to like you, I mean really like you), but he's brown. This is the pink elephant in the Bobby Jindal room. If he were just another white Republican with his views he would blend in like a cowboy hat at a rodeo. That his standard right-wing agenda is delivered from a man of Indian ancestry, however, makes him a standout.
It seems that no one wants to admit this. The Republicans will, of course, use him as an example that they are as meritocratic as the Democrats, just as they did with Sarah Palin, Alan Keyes, and Michael Steele. All of these characters were supposed to convince us that the GOP was not a good ol' boys club, even though pledging allegiance to everything the good ol' boys stand for is a prerequisite for membership in this club of right-wing tokens. Jindal is not an example of Republican egalitarianism, but rather an example of the miscalculations for which the party has become notorious. Obama is thin, ethnic, and a hell of a speaker, and according to anyone who reads Ann Coulter without wanting to punch her in the face, so is Jindal. This, of course, exposes the fact that the Republicans are seeing Obama at the most aesthetic, basic level, and missing the nuances that make him so unique and appealing.
As I have written before, Jindal will not find it easy to draw crowds like Obama with the same tired conservative message of trickle-down economics, defense of guns, and an erosion of reproductive rights. He is a living wedge, whereas Obama is a living bridge. Extending the analogy, it doesn't quite matter that the wedge and the bridge are made of the same material, their purposes are completely different. After discovering all of this for myself, I awaited Jindal's first national appearance to see if everyone else would see what I had discovered. And because I shamelessly engage in schadenfreude, I was hoping he'd bomb out. I just didn't know it would go this well for me.
Jindal's speech last night was terrible, to say the least. Aside from following Obama, who once more riveted a national audience with a terrific and uplifting speech, Jindal delivered his unsurprising speech with the sort of delivery you see on post-late night TV; three in the morning when you can't sleep and wake up to watch what's on during those mysterious sleep hours. To really understand how he sounded, imagine yourself on that couch at three in the morning when you turn on some infomercial plugging a blender that can make atoms of bricks (but all I need is a banana shake...) or a juicer that makes it more complicated than it needs to be to eat an apple. The type of dialogue that goes on between the hosts of these drool-inducing torture sessions and the mark made to look like an interested buyer might properly describe what Jindal sounded like.
That, or think of your high school principal delivering a message to an assembly of students. Either way, it was a laughable attempt to mirror anything Obama has done in his rise to the top. Obama wouldn't deliver a speech that poorly even if he had to give one singing the praises of Rupert Murdoch. The simple fact is that Jindal doesn't have nearly the charisma that the President possesses. But God bless the Republicans for thinking he did, it offered great laughs. The worst part, perhaps, is that nothing in Jindal's speech was a riveting departure from what the Republicans have been spewing ever since Obama got in office. The GOP is trying hard to recast themselves as the fiscally responsible paragons that they were not during the free-spending Bush years, and Jindal tried hard, too. The problem is that the message is falling on deaf ears. The country will not support a do-nothing approach from a party that many see as being mainly responsible for this financial mess. Changing the spokesman doesn't matter, just like changing global warming's name to climate change didn't matter. Either way, people don't like it and want to be rid of it.
The speech was bad enough, its message derivative enough, but then Jindal had to bring up the K word. To somehow suggest that government is not needed, that it's in fact detrimental to Americans by conjuring the response to Hurricane Katrina is a major problem for any Republican. You see, the response to Hurricane Katrina doesn't prove that government is inept, it just proved that the Bush administration was inept. Perhaps that is the greatest secret of the GOP; that they could argue so effectively against government because they prove time and again just how bad they are at governing. Their failures are merely proofs of their message: We (the government) are bad, stupid, and corrupt. The Republicans are out to prove it, apparently, and doing a heckuva job (Brownie).
Really Bobby, this was not nearly the coming out party everyone in your party wanted it to be; not even close. In fact, it probably knocked you down a few notches since even Republicans have been voicing their displeasure with your speech. You told us Americans can do anything last night. But all we've been hearing lately is how Republicans want us to do nothing. Cognitive dissonance is not a good party mantra, no matter how you dice it.
On the positive side, I woke up at about three in the morning last night and ended up purchasing a super blender from an infomercial on TV. I guess I actually believed the host and what he told the crowd member he brought up for a supposed impromptu demonstration. I mean, this thing was crushing bricks! I simply had to get it. Perhaps somehow after Jindal's speech, the usually cheesy dialogue didn't seem so ridiculous, anymore. Can't wait for my shakes!

